Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jeremy Faust, MD's avatar

Just a quick note to thank former US Surgeon General Dr. Jerome Adams for tweeting out today's Inside Medicine.

https://twitter.com/jeromeadamsmd/status/1617566641293869109?s=10

Expand full comment
Daniel Halperin's avatar

Thanks Dr Faust for putting this out there, I certainly agree that NON-ILLNESS (what are officially termed "unnatural") deaths being incorrectly attributed to Covid is, at most, only a tiny problem.

HOWEVER, the issue of OTHER illnesses leading to miscategorized "Covid" deaths is something I've been looking closely at for well over a year now, and that's where we disagree. FYI the article I mentioned working on last week, in this forum, regarding the question of overcounting of Covid deaths, was published this morning in Time magazine (a full year after I first started pitching an earlier version to several major newspapers):

https://time.com/6249841/covid-19-no-longer-a-public-health-emergency/

(There probably shouldn’t be a paywall issue, especially if you haven’t read a Time article in a while?)

Fortuitously, only yesterday I happened to hear about a new study out of Denmark, actually the first rigorous study on this question published in a peer reviewed journal, that confirms the (rather large!) overcounting of Covid deaths. Luckily, Time allowed me to include mention of the study at the last moment; it certainly seemed worth delaying the publication by a day…

And yes, I know that Dr. Faust and probably most of you already disagree, perhaps even without reading what I’ve written, but isn’t it healthy to at least occasionally try to see the other side of an argument?

By the way, the authors of that Danish study also looked carefully at the data for excess deaths: It’s very clear, if you just look at the table in their article (which I linked to), that while official “Covid” deaths exploded a year ago, excess deaths hardly even budged…

And Dr. Faust, I hate to request this just one more time, but especially since I cited Dr Wen's articles several times in my piece, can you please forward this message to her?

Thank you,

Daniel Halperin, PhD

Adjunct Full Professor, Gillings School of Global Public Health, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

danielhalperin.web.unc.edu ; www.amazon.com/Facing-COVID-Without-Panic-Epidemiologist-ebook/dp/B08D25GQX6

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts